Friday, November 13, 2026

Heroic Pastor Cannot Stop Mob Justice and Racial Intimidation

Circulated as a Postcard: Documenting the 1935 Columbus, Texas Lynching


Tuesday, November 12, 1935, Columbus, TX ― The mob jeered Episcopal Minister C. G, Marmion when he stood on the roof of a car and begged a White mob to spare the lives of two Black boys from the lynch rope. “Please let the law take its course,” he pleaded to a crowd that had fallen silent. I told them that they didn’t want the blood of this crime on their hands, or to stain Columbus and Colorado County.

Earlier in the evening the mob had come together to deliver their depraved version of justice as retribution for the murder of 19-year-old Geraldine Kollmann. All the news paper accounts mention that she was the valedictorian of the 1934 high school class, as if this played some part in her death. Kollmann had not pursued higher education by all reports had not been an exceptionally beloved member of the Colorado County community, but she was a White girl who had been assaulted and killed on October 17; her body had been found in Cummins Creek by her brother.

Sheriff Frank Hoegemeyer responded immediately, as did the volunteer fire department to assist in recovery of Kollmann’s body. While the sheriff reportedly suspected murder from the beginning the responding firemen and the large crowd of onlookers had stomped around in the pecan orchard and the river bank destroying any potential evidence.

Kollmann’s funeral was held at her family’s home three days later and the mood of White people in the county was one of anger and resentment. The funeral was presided over by local Lutheran Minister William Flachmeier also spoke to those gathered asking them to, “not seek revenge or take violent action in the name of Geraldine.”

Those in attendance weren’t listening, and as the funeral was going on Sheriff Hoegemeyer was preparing to make arrests based on, well it’s not really said. He had conducted interviews with the family and neighbors but had not found any witnesses. While he was doing these interviews he also spoke to one of the physicians who had acted as coroner. The doctor informed the sheriff that Kollmann had been sexually assaulted by at least two men, and he believed it was after death.

As so often in southern cases regarding a White woman the sheriff had already decided that it was likely a Black man who had committed the crime. He had interviewed an older Black sharecropper who reported that two boys he knew had passed by the river south of town on their way to look for work harvesting pecans.

The two were local Black teens, 15-year-old Ernest Collins and 16-year-old Benny Mitchell. Hoegemeyer proceeded to arrest the two boys for being Black in a county where a White girl had been murdered. Having asked the physician who told him that Kollmann had been not to share that information, the doctor had decided to tell anyone he knew. So when he had been in Columbus getting arrest warrants the sheriff took the temperature of the town and made the decision to take his suspects to Houston for holding. While interviews with Mitchell’s Aunt proved he had a strong alibi and that there was another Black man, who was known for his violence, named Joe in the area the Sheriff didn’t even do a casual investigation and began working with a Texas Ranger named Davenport to get confessions from the two boys.

As was the common situation in the south neither Collins or Mitchell were illiterate, the separate but equal school they went to had failed them and they both had dropped out to find work after fourth grade. While in Houston Hoegemeyer had written confessions prepared for the boys to sign, a document neither could read to to see what they were confessing too.

Approximately three weeks later the sheriff and one of his deputies were transferring the two boys back to Columbus for a hearing in juvenile court. This was another precipitating factor in the mob’s development and actions. I was well known that neither boy could face adult charges under Texas law and even if convicted would only be sentenced to serving in a youth work camp until age 21.

The sheriff and a deputy tried to sneak the boys back into Columbus under the cover of darkness and by taking a back road, reportedly seldom used, when they were stopped by several cars that yielded 10 masked men who took the boys into their custody.

Word had spread rapidly around the county and mob formed to unleash White justice in the memory of Geraldine Kollmann. It was the rumor of a mob spreading that first got the attention of Reverend Marmion and he had spent most of his evening trying to get a line on the mob when he accidently discovered a line of cars pulling up around a gigantic old oak tree south of Columbus.

When Marmion had begged the mob not to commit the crime they jeered him, a man pulled him off the car to the ground. When he got up and approached the men placing the roped on the boy’s neck he was blocked and threatened, “I heard them begging for mercy and the crowd just got loader and more demanding of blood, for my own safety I left feeling disgusted.” He later gave an eyewitness testimony to a senate committee investigating lynching.

The mob executed two illiterate Black boys who had only been looking for work and when forced signed a confession. While Marmion stated he recognized members of the mob, and the sheriff and Justice of the Peace E.C. Thrower said there would be an inquiry it died before it began. County Attorney O.P. Moore stated no crime had been committed, that he didn’t believe it was a mob action just, “I consider their action and expression of the will of the people.”

There would be no outlet for the families of the two boys either as Colorado County Judge H.P. Hahn told the press, “I am strongly opposed to mob violence and favor the orderly process of law.” He stressed his point further so no one could mistake his point; “The fact that the two Negros who so brutally murdered Miss Kollmann could not be adequately punished by the law because of their ages prevents me from condemning those citizens who meted out justice last night to the ravishing murderers last night.”

Despite this and massive support from the Columbus Chamber of Commerce and the two local papers and interesting turn occurred, the lynching of the two boys became the most famous event in both Columbus and Colorado County. Both prominent Black newspapers, the Chicago Defender and the Pittsburgh Courier covered the case and the Federation of Texas Women’s Clubs spoke out strongly regarding the case and th need for anti-lynching laws.

Charles Gershan Marmion was noted as a hero by churches across Texas. The Houston Clericus, and association of Episcopal clergy, adopted a resolution declaring, “All right-thinking Christians will commend the example of Mr., Marmion.” His bishop Clinton Simone Quin sent him a short telegram simply saying, “Proud of you boy, God Bless.” In 1940 Marmion was called to testify regarding his experience before a subcommittee of the on the Judiciary in the U.S. Senate that was considering a federal antilynching law (Finally passed in 2022). Marmion was consecrated Bishop of Kentucky on February 2, 1954 and became one of the nations best known clergym he retired in 1974 and died in 2000 at age 95.

 

Sources:

Stein, Bill. “Colorado County Protects Womanhood: The Murder of Geraldine Kollmann and the Subsequent Lynching of the Accused.” The Southwestern Historical Quarterly 108, no. 4 (2005): 440–66. http://www.jstor.org/stable/30240422.

United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on the Judiciary. Crime of Lynching: Hearings Before a Subcommittee...on H.R. 801...Feb. 6, 7, March 5, 12, 13, 1940. United States: n.p., 1940.

Lynching in Texas files (newspaper article from Columbus Texas Nov. 12, 1935