![]() |
| Denver Police Photo of Preston Porter Jr. |
Friday,
November 16, 1900, Lincoln County, Colorado ― With all the hyperbole that
Yellow Journalism allows the Denver Post proclaimed the murder of 12-year-old
Louise Frost “The most fiendish crime ever perpetrated in Colorado.” They did
not report the murder of 15-year-old Preston (John) Porter Jr on this day the
same way.
Porter
Jr. was removed from a train by force and chained to the railroad this
afternoon in front of a mob of 300 Whites, he was then burned alive. The mob
lynched the Black child for the murder of the White one even as he repeatedly
insisted he and his brother and father were innocent. His father and brother
were key in why Porter Jr. was murdered.
Frost
was 12-years-old when she went missing on the 8th of November. The
newspaper accounts do not have a lot of detail regarding her murder; other than
she was stabbed 14 times and had been sexually assaulted. Very standard story
in the Jim Crow era where the more salacious details are prominent but there is
little about why she was alone or any details that could lead to a conclusion
other than she was supposedly stalked by a Negro. Some stories say she was on
her way home from school and others say she was driving a horse and buggy to
get the mail. None of the stories fail to mention, “Miss Frost was well
developed for her age.”
Lincoln
County Sheriff John W. Freeman began immediately tracking Preston Porter and
his two sons, all three Black, from a railroad work camp that was known as Lake
Station; a now vanished spot with a post office and saloon that furnished to workers
for the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railroad lines. The Porters were “Section
Men” responsible for patrolling and doing maintenance for six miles of track just
east of Limon.
It
is uncertain, other than them being transient Negros, why Sheriff Freeman
focused almost exclusively on the Porters. There were reports from two boys who
said they saw two dark skinned men walking the tracks near where Frost’s body
had been found. While this might have sounded unusual it very easily could have
been the Porters since they were working that section of track. In fact, there
were also eyewitness reports of a suspicious White man with fresh scratches on
his face in Flagler, 35 miles west of Limon. A torn necktie of a local young
business man was found at the scene as well, because it is a lonely spot separate
from any railroad stop this discovery was a little odd and the Colorado Daily Chieftain
in Pueblo even reported that, “the police fancy this maybe a valuable clue.”
The
next day the Associated Press had a report that Sheriff Freeman at the behest
of Richard Frost, Louise’s father, brought in bloodhounds. These hounds
reportedly tracked a scent over a mile before losing it in tall grass near Big
Sandy Creek. Then the next day it was reported that a posse with the hounds
picked up the scent again and were in pursuit. It was even reported in the
Rocky Mountain News that arrests had been made in Flagler and in Wray another
farming town 130 miles south of Limon.
This
seems to raise questions, except for Sheriff Freeman who had arranged for
Denver Police and Pinkerton agents to search Denver for the three Porters,
there was no reason given for this if the murderer was still being tracked
across the prairie or prime suspects arrested,
Then
suddenly on November 12th all these loose ends were dropped as
Denver police took all the Porters into custody and that Sheriff Freeman was on
his way to Denver to interview them, with a focus on Preston Porter Jr. The boy
was thrown to the wolves against all reported evidence in the press. He and his
family had the valid reason to be in Denver, it was where they had to go to
collect their pay from the railroad.
In
Denver the police had put Porter Jr. in isolation and in what was called a
sweat box, a single small cell outside the main jail. Sheriff Freeman first
interviewed the boy and according to witnesses is where Freeman made threats to
lynch his brother and father. Porter Jr.
was also beaten by Denver police officers and Pinkerton agents attempting to coerce
a confession. Then word got out that the “Fiend who killed Louise Frost was in
the jail and White mobs surrounded the jail demanding he be released to justice.
After
three days of this brutal interviewing Porter Jr finally broke and confessed.
It was the 15th of November and at that moment his fate was sealed. Freeman
decided to return to Limon with his prisoner although he had been advised by Fourth
Judicial District Attorney Henry McAllister and Governor Charles Thomas to
wait, he decided that mob justice was preferable to waiting any longer.
At
6:42 p.m. the train carrying Porter Jr. And Freeman was stopped by a mob of
about 300 people between Limon and Lake Station, at the exact spot Louise Frost
was allegedly discovered, Porter Jr. was roughly removed from the train and
chained to the railroad tracks. Leaders of the mob then began beating Porter
Jr. and pilling wood around his legs, They poured kerosene on the wood and
Porter. Porter Jr. protested and begged for his life, he screamed his innocence,
it was all ignored and R. W. Frost stepped from the mob, struck a match on his
trousers and set the fire to consume a teenager.
The
White newspapers across the country uniformly defended the mob, discussing only
the nature of his supposed crime and not mentioning the horrific penalty, or in
a strange way separating the gruesome way Porter Jr. was murdered from his identity
and personhood.
Most
reporting praised the mob for their organization and not emotional way they
carried out their duty, again separating the rage that exists within a mob of
300 people who could Immolate a child alive and the need to present White as
right. The depraved indifference of the press, the government and the legal
system isn’t shocking, except for the geography. Colorado was in no way immune
to Judge Lynch however it was rare outside the deep south for executions to be
this brutal and inhumane.
Once
more the words, “by persons unknown,” entered the legal record. While there
were numerous individuals identified by the public no arrests were ever made,
there was no investigation. Preston Porter and his son Arthur had been released
from jail and quietly returned to Kansas.
In
2018 a group of volunteers erected an Equal Justice Initiative Lynching Marker
as part of the EJI’s Memorializing Racial Terror: Lynching Markers in the
United States project.
Sources:
Ray, Ronny. Chronicles of a Predatory Nation. N.p.:
Outskirts Press, 2025.
Modupe Labode. “The ‘Stern, Fearless Settlers of the
West’: Lynching, Region, and Capital Punishment in Early Twentieth-Century
Colorado.” Western Historical Quarterly 45, no. 4 (2014): 389–409.
https://doi.org/10.2307/westhistquar.45.4.0389.
Preston ‘John’ Porter Jr.’s story (2020) The
Colorado Lynching Memorial Project. Available at:
https://www.coloradolynchingmemorial.org/.
Prendergast , A. (2018) The murder of Preston Porter Jr.
and Colorado’s grim history of lynchings, Colorado Lynching Memorial.
Available at: https://www.coloradolynchingmemorial.org/post/westword-article.
More information gathered from Colorado Historic Newspapers
Project



No comments:
Post a Comment