Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Columbine Mine Massacre: Bloodshed, Labor Strife, and the Road to Reform

The Columbine Massacre monument in Lafayette Cemetery, Colorado.
Photograph by Doug Geiling. Source: Boulder Beat

 

ꜱᴇʀᴇɴᴇ, ᴄᴏ—ɴᴏᴠᴇᴍʙᴇʀ 21, 1927 — Striking workers at the Columbine Mine were slaughtered here today as the Rocky Mountain Fuel Company called upon Colorado State Ranger Militia, Unit 325 to forcefully drive off 500 protestors and end a strike by the miners that had slowed production since October 18.

Slowed production because the Columbine Mine was the only mine in the state that had not gone on a full strike but had scabs still mining coal. It seems incongruous to order an attack at the only mine still in production, however Serene is a complete company town and so the combination of miners families being dislodged for scabs and the pressure of the horrid conditions that persisted brought in hundreds of miners from other mines in the northern part of the state, miners who had successfully stopped production at those mines.

The strike was just the most recent skirmish in the long coal war that Colorado had been witnessing between mine owners and miners almost since the state joined the union, a war that had seen many terrible events highlighted by the Ludlow massacre of April, 1914 where the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company killed 25 miners or their family members when they and the national Guard raided a tent city.

The 1927 strike had begun on October 18 when the miners with the nascent Colorado unions followed the call of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW). The IWW allegedly called for a wide strike in many industries to protest the executions of anarchists Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti who had been convicted of murder and robbery in an infamous 1921 crime. Whether this was true didn’t matter for the miners as they now had support in striking against the mines.

Colorado mine owners already had the reputation of being heinous and cruel. For years they had employed women and children as well as men allowing them to pay lower wages in even more dangerous conditions. However, some also ran company towns and didn’t pay miners for “dead work” which was the work of shoring up tunnel supports and ventilation but wasn’t part of coal or mineral production.

Because of this refusal to pay for “dead work,” Colorado was quite familiar with disasters from unsafe conditions.  Tragedies such as the Hastings disaster of 1917 where 121 miners died, the Sopris and Oakdale mines each had accidents killing 27 and 31 men respectively where as common in Colorado as in West Virginia.

Colorado miners were basically enslaved labor living in dingey, dirty camps breathing deadly air and drinking poisoned water so other men could be rich. They were angry and ready to fight. However, the owners were also prepared; they were accustomed to the miners acquiescing and refused to bend to men asking for basic human rights, and they because this strike had shutdown production at 113 mines they had the militia power of the state backing them. Regardless this time the miners had the numbers, approximately 8,400 miners were striking for something better.

Across the state law enforcement had arrested picketers and charged them with petty things like public disruption, loitering, noise violations leading to jail time. In jail beatings were common as were shuttling IWW members, and to lesser degree members of the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA), between jails so their lawyers couldn’t find them. It was a shell game and the corrupted officials knew how to play it better than the miners.

While corruption and indifference where the major issue the miners had to confront, the backing of the IWW didn’t exactly help their cause. The IWW was considered a radical communist organization, getting a seat at the table when the IWW represented you was nearly impossible. The president of the Colorado State Federation of Labor Earl Hoage refused to recognize the strike are legitimate. ‘The miners do have some genuine grievances; he stated to the press. “Regardless we can’t support them, the AFL cannot as long as a radical, renegade organization such as the IWW is involved.”

Hoage wasn’t alone in this opinion; Thomas Annear, the state industrial commissioner appointed to represent labor, choose not to represent labor, He had strong feelings that the IWW was causing unnecessary and illegal strikes, and wherever the organization operated there was unrest. Annear had gotten a statement from all the state commissioners stating that because they gave no notice all strikes north of Denver were illegal. Annear would later have a significant role in the legal outcome of today’s events.

On the morning of November 21st 500 strikers and protesters approached the now gated and guarded Serene. Inside the gates were Weld County Sheriff’s Deputies, representatives of Rocky Mountain Fuel Company and the militia, who had been recommissioned as “Strike Police” were spread out near the company office. Annear, and State Budget Commissioner Sterling B. Lacy were there as well. Also, on site were several reporters, most sympathetic to the state and mine owners. Another important witness was newly appointed RMFC and other owners. President Merle Vincent.

The marchers arrived at the gates and demanded the right to meet their families and meet with the non-striking workers to convince them to join them. The were denied and anger and resentment rose. Strike police head Louis Schref went to the gates to meet the marchers. He shouted that he wanted to talk to the leaders, but met a response of a chorus of voices shouting, “We are the leaders” came back.” Scherf tried several times before retreating into the office.

The protesting miners then advanced toward the gates, two rows of men with rifles were aimed at them as they advanced. The miners were also demanding access to the post office and school. At the gates one of the prominent strike leaders, Adam Ball was grabbed and pulled over the fence where he was being beaten into unconsciousness by members of Scherf’s state police. The protestors tore down the fence to save Ball, not to advance. Once they did tear down gates and fist fights and brawls broke out. Scherf’ fired two shots into the crowd which was followed by rifle shots from the  strike police suddenly from the right side a machine gun started cutting men down, apparently from someone employed by the mine owners. When the chaos stopped four men were dead two more mortally wounded and 60 were injured.

The next day at a hastily arranged Weld County Coroners Inquest Scherf lied about the situation insisting there was no interactions and that when he first saw the mob the They already over thru the gates and were beating his men with clubs and bricks. He insisted they had used the weapons for self-protection. Annear supported this version of events even when confronted with facts

What Scherf said at the inquest was immediately repudiated by other eyewitnesses including RMFC President Merle Vincent and the wives of the men, prior to this they had marched with their men, but in this instance, because of the gates and heavy militia presence, they came in after shots were fired, and they saw the violence and the indifference Sherf and Annear gave to the injured.

The dead were mostly local family men, some lived outside the company town

  • Jerry Davis (21). The youngest victim, he was carrying an American flag at the front of the crowd—later found riddled with 17 bullet holes—and died in the hospital hours later.
  • Rene Jacques (26). A miner from Louisville, he died in the hospital later that same day.
  • John Eastenes (34). A married father of six from Lafayette, he was killed instantly when police opened fire.
  • Nick Spanudakhis (34). Also from Lafayette, he was fatally wounded at the gate and died within minutes.
  • Mike Vidovich (35). A miner from Erie, he survived the initial attack before succumbing to his injuries a week later.
  • Frank Kovich. A miner from Erie, he died in the hospital hours after the shooting.

 

The immediate effect of the massacre recent inheritor of RMFC, Josephine Roche issued a statement recognizing the strikers’ grievances and the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA). This move was a to take the IWW off the table, and it impressively did. As the coal wars began winding down the IWW was effectively broken in Colorado. Roche and Vincent developed a progressive, cohesive management team. Although Annear used his position to block compensation to the dead miners’ families and those wounded because it was deemed an illegal strike, she and Vincent unionized the RMCF mines and gave the unheard-of wage $6.85 a day. Vincent also appeared as a witness in the civil trail but that suit was dismissed three years later

Unlike the Ludlow Massacre the Columbine massacre shifted the industry forward and changed the lives of the major players.

Louis Scherf remained the chief of this version of the state police until it was closed at the end of prohibition in 1932. His direction after the state shut him out. His wife divorced him and took custody of his children.  He fell far out of favor with state officials and a reminder of a more painful time. Although he had survived a lawsuit by the families of Columbine victims. He faded from public life  died in Baltimore in 1947 at the age of 55.

Merle Vincent helped Roche draft the agreement with left the mining industry and joined the Roosevelt Administration in a helped draft the Fair Labor Standards Act (the first federal wage-and-hour law) before taking leadership roles in the Wage and Hour Division. He was accused without much evidence of being a communist by the Dies Un-American Activities Committee in 1943. He continued to serve FDR and in the Department of Labor until 1945. He remained active in progressive and labor activities until his death in 1958 at age 84.

After a decade as president of the Colorado State Federation of Labor Earl Hoage also joined the Roosevelt Administration to help administer and enforce NRA labor provisions and fair-competition codes across Colorado and the Rocky Mountain region. He and Vincent and Roch worked together often as members of the Roosevelt Lasor Department.

Thomas Annear worked with labor to improve laws for the next few years and then was elected state auditor. In that position he became a fierce foe of corruption which led to his defeat in 1939. He remained active in Democratic politics until his death in 1952.

Josephine Roche went on to also serve in the Roosevelt administration as Assistant Secretary of the Treasury from 1933 to 1939. She left the administration to take over the United Mine Workers Health and Welfare Fund. During  her life, Roche was honored by a number of business and civic organizations, and received honorary degrees from Smith College, Oglethorpe University, Mount Holyoke College, and the University of Colorado. She was elected to the Colorado Women’s Hall of Fame in 1986.

 

Sources:

Campbell-Hale, Leigh. Remembering Ludlow But Forgetting the Columbine: The 1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike. United States: University Press of Colorado, 2023.

Gonzales, Michael Robert. A Spirit of Revolt: Conrado Alvillar and the Rank-and-File Wobblies of the 1927–1928 Colorado Coal Strike. N.p.: AK Press, 2026.

Bayard, Charles J. “The 1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike.” Pacific Historical Review 32, no. 3 (1963): 235–50. https://doi.org/10.2307/4492179.

Sam Lowry, “Colorado Miners Strike and Columbine Mine Massacre, 1927,” Libcom.org, accessed November 22, 2026,

Colorado State Library. Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/

Research for this article included examination of fourteen contemporary newspaper accounts accessed through the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection, Colorado State Library.


No comments:

Post a Comment